Withdrawal of the GCD proposal
On 4 November 2026, the European Commission published its new Work Programme, setting out the main policy and legislative initiatives planned for 2027. The Work Programme confirmed the Commission’s intention to withdraw its proposal for a Green Claims Directive (“GCD”) within six months (see our blog post for further detail).
The GCD proposal, first published by the Commission in March 2023 (see our blog post), was intended to complement the Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive (“EmpCo”) by setting minimum criteria that companies making claims to consumers in the EU about the environmental benefits and performance of their products or services needed to meet, as well as minimum criteria for environmental labelling schemes. The planned withdrawal follows stalled negotiations between the European Parliament and the Council in summer 2025.
The GCD proposal at a glance
The GCD would have covered voluntary “green claims” in EU business-to-consumer (“B2C”) transactions, including commercial messages, images, labels and names stating or implying that a product or trader has a positive, neutral, comparatively lower or improved environmental impact. The proposed requirements applied to EU-based companies and businesses based outside the EU making voluntary environmental claims directed at EU consumers.
Green claims would have required scientific substantiation, fair comparisons and advance independent verification by an accredited verifier issuing an EU-recognised certificate of conformity. Aggregate scoring of a product’s overall environmental impact would have been prohibited. The proposal excluded most financial services, and notably did not prescribe a single substantiation methodology, although it proposed giving the Commission the power to later adopt delegated acts.
To reduce consumer confusion and unfair competition arising from unreliable environmental claims and proliferating labels, the proposal set minimum rules for new environmental labelling schemes, requiring that new private schemes have greater environmental ambition than existing ones (and prior national authority approval).
The GCD proposal recognised that climate-related claims (such as “climate neutral”, “carbon neutral”, etc) based on the use of carbon offsets or carbon credits are particularly confusing and so the proposal required companies to report separately any greenhouse gas emission offsets used, specify whether those offsets relate to emission reductions or removals, specify the share of total emissions that are addressed through offsetting, and specify the methodology used (to ensure that all offsets relied upon are of high quality and accounted for correctly and transparently). The proposal did not ban the use of carbon offsets, although it did say that companies should prioritise the reduction of emissions in their own organisation or value chain instead of relying on carbon offsets.
For more information on the GCD, see our blog posts:
European Commission publishes proposal for a Green Claims Directive to combat greenwashing
EU Parliament adopts first reading position on the Green Claims Directive
EU: Council adopts negotiating position on the Green Claims Directive
How should companies prepare for the EU’s Green Claims Directive?
EmpCo: the continuing framework for tackling greenwashing
The GCD was intended to complement EmpCo, which started applying on 27 September 2026.
EmpCo amended the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (“UCPD”) and Consumer Rights Directive (“CRD”), strengthening rules on environmental claims and sustainability labels and harmonising point-of-sale information on areas including guarantee rights and durability.
EmpCo blacklists certain practices, deeming them automatically unfair. Offending practices include but are not limited to: sustainability labels not backed by a qualifying scheme or public authority; unjustified generic environmental claims; misleading durability and repairability claims; and neutrality claims based on offsetting emissions. Other practices require case-specific assessment. For instance, environmental performance claims need verifiable commitments, realistic implementation plans with measurable targets, and regular independent verification.
EmpCo also strengthens pre-contractual information requirements for in-store and online sales in a variety of ways. An example of this is the requirement for traders to disclose applicable EU reparability scores or, where none exists and provided the producer has made the information available to them, to provide information on spare parts, repair instructions and restrictions.
What does the withdrawal mean in practice?
The GCD proposal’s more detailed EU-wide substantiation and verification framework will not take effect. In practice, this means a number of things:
No pre-publication verification framework
The GCD proposal would have required independent verification before covered environmental claims were put to the market. One lost benefit of the proposal is therefore that it offered a pre-publication verification framework that could have given businesses greater predictability about the permissibility of their environmental claims.
No harmonised substantiation criteria
Another practical challenge is the loss of a common EU framework for evidencing claims. EmpCo is prescriptive about what traders cannot say, but the GCD intended to supplement this by telling them how to evidence their environmental claims. The GCD would have set requirements for matters such as scientific evidence, relevant life-cycle impacts and the basis for comparisons. Without that framework, national authorities and courts will continue to assess whether evidence supports a claim under the existing rules, leaving more room for differences in evidential expectations and enforcement practice. For companies operating across the EU, a harmonized approach might have reduced the administrative costs that come with a fragmented regulatory landscape.
Looking ahead
It remains possible that the GCD will be revived or returned in some form. The Work Programme explained that the withdrawal was due to the proposal being unlikely to secure timely Council support and, as we explained in our previous blog posts covering negotiations between the Parliament and the Council, a number of disagreements arose over scope and compliance burdens. Nonetheless, there is still scope for further substantiation and verification rules to be proposed in the future to enhance the effectiveness of EmpCo in combatting greenwashing.
On 11 November 2026, the Commission presented its Proposal for a Digital Fairness Act (“DFA”), which would replace the UCPD with a directly applicable Regulation (as opposed to a Directive) while broadly retaining EmpCo’s existing greenwashing rules. This will not restore the GCD’s proposed framework, but it does re-enforce EmpCo’s continuing importance and the EU’s continued scrutiny of sustainability claims. The parallel proposal to revise the Consumer Protection Cooperation (“CPC”) Regulation would also strengthen cross-border enforcement, including by enabling the Commission to investigate large-scale infringements of EU rules directly.
Key takeaways for businesses
Overall, businesses should remain focussed on meeting EmpCo’s requirements: their existing duties to substantiate environmental claims remain firmly in place.
To comply with EmpCo, businesses should ensure that they review their consumer-facing environmental claims and sustainability labels, assessing each against EmpCo’s substantiation requirements. Also, pre-contractual information requirements should be met across in-store and online channels. And lastly, businesses operating across the EU should keep up to date with how EmpCo is being transposed at national levels by the various Member States (see our Transposition Tracker).
For more information on EmpCo, see our Quick Quide.

/Passle/5f6c57568cb62a0d7c9eadee/SearchServiceImages/2026-01-28-14-47-21-400-697a2179e8715be98458d80a.jpg)
/Passle/5f6c57568cb62a0d7c9eadee/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-20-11-42-40-823-6b0032308a15057993598ede.jpg)
/Passle/5f6c57568cb62a0d7c9eadee/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-20-09-57-45-170-6b001999b41247729a83b69e.jpg)
/Passle/5f6c57568cb62a0d7c9eadee/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-19-09-56-51-784-6afec7e353016789c40887be.jpg)
/Passle/5f6c57568cb62a0d7c9eadee/SearchServiceImages/2026-11-18-18-38-53-489-6afdf0bdf00d200e8757cb13.jpg)