This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 3 minute read

California Climate Disclosure Laws Face Temporary Partial Federal Court Block

On 9 November 2026, the Ninth Circuit issued a decision in Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, No. 25-5327, addressing whether California’s SB 253 (Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act) and SB 261 (Climate-Related Financial Risk Act) should be paused while the courts determine the merits of the challenge. The court left SB 253’s Scope 1 and 2 emissions reporting requirements in place, but ruled that challengers were entitled to preliminary relief against SB 253’s Scope 3 requirement and the full suite of SB 261’s climate-related financial risk disclosures. It further remanded for the district court to determine whether the Scope 3 provisions can be severed from the rest of SB 253. This is a preliminary-injunction decision, not a final judgment striking down either law.

The decision draws a distinction between disclosures about a company’s own emissions and those addressing its wider value chain or future climate risks. For Scope 1 and 2, the majority treated disclosures about direct emissions and purchased-energy emissions as commercial speech: standardized, factual information about a company’s own operations relevant to investment, lending and insurance transactions. It concluded that these requirements likely survive intermediate scrutiny because they directly advance California’s substantial interests in addressing investor information gaps and reducing emissions without being more extensive than necessary. The court did not decide whether the more deferential Zauderer standard applies.

The court took a different approach for Scope 3 reporting, which covers emissions elsewhere in a company’s value chain. The majority viewed those disclosures as noncommercial speech because they concern independent third parties’ activities and are too indirectly connected to the reporting company’s own operations and investment or lending transactions. It therefore applied strict scrutiny. The majority found that California had not adequately justified requiring companies to report this information rather than relying on alternatives, such as voluntary reporting or state-generated estimates, and had not sufficiently demonstrated that mandatory reporting would reduce emissions. It concluded that the Scope 3 requirement was likely unconstitutional and directed the district court to decide whether that requirement could be separated from SB 253, allowing the rest of the statute to remain in effect.

The majority took a similar approach to SB 261, concluding that climate-risk reports compel predictive and normative judgments about climate change, rather than merely factual commercial disclosures. Applying strict scrutiny, it found both less restrictive alternatives and insufficient evidence that the reports would reduce emissions. In November 2025, the Ninth Circuit had already barred enforcement of SB 261, pending appeal. CARB subsequently announced that it would not enforce the January 1, 2026, reporting deadline against any covered entity.

The panel was not unanimous. In a separate opinion concurring in the judgment in part and dissenting in part, Judge Bennett would have applied strict scrutiny to both statutes and preliminarily enjoined them in full, including Scope 1 and 2 reporting.

For companies, the immediate takeaway is that Scope 1 and 2 reporting remains in place. The decision did not suspend or extend CARB’s November 10, 2026, initial reporting deadline, which has now passed. Companies that have not submitted should promptly assess their position under CARB’s first-year enforcement guidance and address any outstanding submission. That guidance permits reporting based on information companies already had or were collecting when CARB issued its December 2024 enforcement notice. For the 2026 cycle only, CARB does not expect emissions data from entities that were neither collecting nor planning to collect such data at that time and requests a statement of non-reporting from those entities. SB 253 generally covers U.S.-formed entities doing business in California with annual revenues exceeding $1 billion.

The Ninth Circuit found SB 253’s Scope 3 reporting requirement likely unconstitutional and reversed the denial of preliminary relief. It specifically directed the district court to address whether the Scope 3 provisions can be severed from the rest of SB 253. The underlying constitutional challenge remains before the district court for a final merits determination; this appellate ruling concerns preliminary relief, not a final judgment invalidating the requirement. Scope 1 and 2 reporting remains in place under the Ninth Circuit’s ruling. However, if the district court determines that the Scope 3 provisions cannot be severed from the rest of SB 253, preliminary relief could extend to the entire statute, including Scope 1 and 2. Any broader enforcement block would depend on further court action. Companies should monitor the mandate, district court proceedings and implementing injunction orders, CARB’s response, and any requests for rehearing or further review before changing compliance plans.

In the meantime, the decision is a reason to reassess reporting priorities, not necessarily to abandon broader climate-related work. While SB 261 reporting remains voluntary under CARB’s stated position, companies should inventory any separate legal, contractual, or investor reporting expectations before scaling back emissions-data collection or climate-risk assessments.

For more information on California’s SB 253 (Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act) and SB 261 (Climate-Related Financial Risk Act), see our Quick Guide. 

Sign up for real-time updates on the latest ESG developments, delivered straight to your inbox - subscribe now!

Tags

blog posts, climate change & environment, corporates, disclosure & reporting, litigation, usa